Incentive pay can give small businesses a big improvement through team motivation and positive creation – and it also helps with the growth of the business! One time, I actually received a small bonus, and I felt like I could conquer the world. But I’ve also seen how poorly defined targets can sometimes spark unhealthy competition.
Incentive pay can also help to reoptimize your entire business operations. Clear steps are available for setting fair goals that blend individual and team rewards – you just need to have flexible plans.
You should work with some clear metrics. Capitalize on the morale improvement from group achievements and be sure to adjust as the firm evolves over time. A one-size-fits-all strategy just doesn’t work here – so good planning helps.
Let’s start working on these things together!
Performance-Based And SPIF Plans
Performance-based incentives will help to improve your team’s motivation and drive the results that you’re going for. You get the chance to reward your employees with some extra benefits when they crush their targets. Your rewards toolbox can also have everything from cash bonuses and commissions to fun prizes on top of the regular pay.
Short-term incentive funds (SPIFs) can help to energize your sales team’s performance levels. These quick-hit bonus programs push your people to smash their goals in set time windows. You could give $500 to the team members who lock in ten premium package sales during this month. Targeted incentives can help during those frustrating, slow periods. A small difference could turn a sluggish season into a real winner.
SPIFs work their magic by creating excitement and enthusiasm in your team. Your team members love seeing those quick wins and instant rewards instead of waiting around for yearly bonuses. Just to give you an example, a car dealership could give a luxurious weekend getaway to the first salesperson who crushes five vehicle sales within a week.
Program design starts with some easy-to-reach goals. Your team won’t get fired up if you set impossible targets that cause burnout.
Looking to learn more about an incentive, rebate
or reward program for your business?
DemoCurious about costs?
Try our instant pricing calculator:
A sales target that’s just 10% above normal will usually get better results compared to demanding a massive 50% jump. Crystal-clear performance incentives are best for everyone. Your team will need to completely understand what they should do to grab those rewards.
Your coffee shop could give the baristas a $100 bonus to improve their customer satisfaction scores by five points during this month. These types of targeted incentives often generate good wins for businesses. A small tech company could improve quarterly sales by 30% with a SPIF that rewards team members who sign up new subscription customers.
Success often comes from connecting your rewards to business goals that matter.
Equity Options
Your success aligns naturally with the company’s success through profit sharing and stock options. Your extra effort can also directly affect the money that you take home – so you’ll naturally work a bit harder to improve the numbers. Money conversations matter, and nothing motivates quite like seeing your wallet grow along with the company profits.
I’ve watched some profit-sharing bonuses completely change how the workplace culture operates. Your team will start working together more closely since everyone gets rewarded when the company hits its targets. It’s fun to celebrate wins together. You can also watch your bonus increase as the business grows over time.
Stock ownership programs build an even stronger bond between you and your company’s future. You’ll start thinking like an owner instead of just another employee once you own shares. Your focus changes to long-term growth and moves that create long-term results. There’s just something about being able to tell people that you own a part of the company where you work.
Employees sometimes like stock options over direct cash bonuses. Your stock options allow you to build wealth over time as the company expands. These programs help employees stay around longer and cut back on turnover rates, too.
You’ll think twice before jumping ship when you have unvested stock options or future profit-sharing payments still waiting. Businesses use this to draw and hold onto their best people longer.
Each company actually structures its profit sharing differently. Some organizations reward you through quarterly bonuses with goals. Other businesses save everything for a fun year-end payout instead. Your work connects directly to the rewards. That connection makes a real difference.
Set Realistic Targets And Metrics
Take a close look at your team’s past track record to help you set some basic goals. Their past achievements can give you an idea about what they can accomplish. They can also give you a good foundation for planning ahead.
Market conditions can play a giant role, too. The state of your industry, whether it’s struggling or thriving, should help you optimize your targets. When you set aggressive goals during tough times, it’ll only frustrate your team. Every team member deserves some personalized goals that match their experience level.
Experts might grow with ambitious targets, while newcomers need more manageable benchmarks. Each person on your team should feel stretched. But they should also feel confident that they can succeed.
The right balance can help. Easy goals won’t inspire any growth, and unrealistic targets will crush spirits. At my old company, a new sales manager suddenly doubled our quotas.
That caused zero wins and a completely demoralized team. Your team needs some clear-cut success metrics. They need to know what they’re going for and how you’ll measure it.
Instead of vague goals like “improve customer happiness,” pick numbers that everyone can track. Stay flexible with your targets. Watch for signs that your team misses their goals month after month.
Then, reassess your strategy. Your willingness to adjust will show them that you care about setting them up for success. Targets should challenge your team while staying attainable.
They should inspire growth without causing burnout. Each person responds differently to pressure. Some people are better with big challenges. But others need smaller stepping stones to help them build their confidence.
Balance Individual And Team Rewards
You’ll get some better results from your incentive pay program when you’re able to balance the individual rewards with the team’s success goals. Most small businesses usually have a hard time finding this balance in their compensation plans. Team rewards can improve employee unity and general job satisfaction.
A stair-step bonus system also rewards your top performers while encouraging other team members to push themselves even more. Your employees can earn bigger rewards as they’re able to reach higher performance levels. But you’ll need to structure these systems to stay away from unhealthy competition. Your sales team members are able to earn their own commissions while working toward shared targets that multiply everyone’s bonuses.
This usually prevents your star performers from outshining their teammates too much. Team celebrations naturally strengthen the bonds that these incentive programs are trying to create. The whole department can share in the success when you celebrate together with dinner after hitting a big goal.
It shows everyone how their personal work changes group success. These shared moments create better teamwork and shared support. Your employees who manage basic but less visible tasks deserve recognition just the same as those with more known achievements.
Your incentive program can naturally give you some team spirit when it rewards the different types of performance. Your team members like to work harder when their success actually helps their colleagues succeed as well. Customer service teams especially show this effect because shared goals naturally cause better performance.
The positive feeling of helping others succeed can motivate people even more than personal gain alone. The timing of your incentive payouts helps their effectiveness.
Quick rewards work well for basic tasks, while harder projects need longer-term incentives instead. Clear communication and transparent tracking improve your team members’ ability to see how their work earns personal and team rewards.
Adapt Incentives For Changing Goals
Your incentive program has to adapt much faster because your business and the market conditions can change over time. When I first started my own small business, our incentive program seemed so perfect – until we added three new product lines. That was when everything just completely fell apart.
Your incentive strategy will need some non-stop attention, just like a living organism. Businesses learned this big lesson during the pandemic. Businesses that adjusted their rewards faster saw happier teams than people who remained more static.
General results get better when employees can help shape the incentive program. After all, they know what actually motivates them to work a bit harder. Our quarterly meetings also let the staff recommend some changes to our bonus structure. Their productive ideas helped to create a system that works.
Different people often want different rewards, too. Some of your employees might like extra vacation time instead of cash bonuses. Others might like more opportunities to develop their career skills. Businesses giving these flexible options keep their employees around much longer.
Flexible rewards make a big part of your strategy when your business needs to change in a new direction faster. Let’s say you’re launching something innovative or trying to break into another market. Your rewards also need to match up with these goals.
Just to give you an example, we recently prioritized online sales, so we started giving out bigger commissions for web transactions. Your incentive program shouldn’t be treated as something fixed. Businesses always adjust their rewards based on what’s going on in the market and what they’re trying to achieve.
Listen to your team’s feedback and look at your performance data, too – that’ll show you where those incentives work and where they need some change.
Diversify Monetary And Non-Monetary Rewards
Money alone won’t make your team happy and motivated. Your employees might love some of the cash bonuses – but a heartfelt thank-you note or a team celebration can also create even bigger results. Business owners know that they should use multiple types of rewards to create an engaging workplace.
Cash rewards like bonuses and commission checks can create instant excitement. Yet there’s a downside – the money tends to disappear and fade faster. Your employees probably won’t even remember what they bought with their holiday bonus once February arrives. These real gestures can create memories that make your employees feel appreciated.
Non-monetary rewards help to create long-term emotional connections that money just can’t deliver. You could host a team lunch to celebrate hitting that big goal together. You might even give team members an extra day off for their birthday.
Easy touches like gift cards or movie tickets can also motivate performance more than cash alone. Public recognition can give you long-lasting results without being too expensive.
Your team members may be at their best and brightest when you point out their achievements in meetings. A personal and handwritten note showing that you see their hard work builds trust in the long term. These authentic moments often strengthen the bonds between you and your employees.
You should find the best combination of monetary and non-monetary rewards for your team. Some people like professional growth ahead of cash bonuses. Others might like flexible schedules over gift cards. When you get more creative with the different reward options, then you’ll connect with each person in ways that matter to them.
Small businesses struggle when they focus too much on only one type of reward. Cash-only incentives can create a shallow relationship that’s focused on quick wins. A strategy based on intangible benefits might leave employees feeling financially unappreciated. The right balance helps to build long-term engagement and motivation.
Address Legal And Ethical Issues
You have to manage incentive pay to stay away from breaking tax and labor laws in your small business. The IRS can slam you with some fines for even small mistakes in bonus payment management. Small business owners often don’t know that their bonuses will need the same tax withholding as their regular paychecks.
Incentive programs usually come with more challenges than just legal compliance. Your bonus structure might accidentally push your employees toward unethical behavior. Staff members who are rewarded only on call volume can produce rushed and hasty conversations with unhappy customers. Your incentive structure will need to build trust throughout your organization.
A real example proves this point. A small sporting goods retailer failed to track bonuses and to withhold taxes. IRS penalties almost destroyed their entire business within just two years.
Poor and unfair bonus systems that welcome shortcuts can damage your company culture. Rebuilding that trust takes some serious time and effort. The bonus system shouldn’t create any type of conflict between team members.
Friendly competition can help to improve performance. However, team-based rewards will welcome collaboration instead of encouraging sabotage. Quick-win financial incentives may improve short-term numbers, but they might also cause employee burnout and rule-bending.
Some staff members might even resort to devious plans just to get their bonuses. Your incentive program should match your company’s core values and its long-term vision. Design your bonus structure to celebrate personal achievements and team success. Clear rules and steady application will help keep favoritism problems at a distance.
Level Up Your Incentives and Rewards
You’ve likely found some of the deeper truths about your team during casual and friendly conversations. Your colleagues might also share frustrations they never mention in formal meetings when you point out the problems that may need some attention. These spontaneous conversations can give you a look into what matters to your team.
Breakthroughs often happen outside of structured settings. “Why” questions in your latest planning sessions can also create the space for real discussions. Your team members will naturally share more ideas when you legitimately listen to them.
Their honest feedback helps everyone to move forward together. You can stay away from overlooking frustrations and tap into creative services that you might have missed before. Regular check-ins, surveys, and open conversations help to stop small problems from becoming serious ones.
Team morale is harmed when people feel ignored. That can give you some increased turnover or a struggling team culture. A schedule that can give you some feedback and continuous improvement can help build an environment where everyone feels heard and appreciated.
We at Level 6 partner with you to bring out the best in your workforce. Our incentive programs help elevate your business performance, whether you’re going for increased sales or higher employee engagement. Your team can benefit from our branded debit cards, employee rewards, and customized sales incentive programs, all designed to deliver measurable results. See how we help successful businesses maximize their ROI and sales performance, and book your free demo today!
Claudine is the Chief Relationship Officer at Level 6. She holds a master’s degree in industrial/organizational psychology. Her experience includes working as a certified conflict mediator for the United States Postal Service, a human performance analyst for Accenture, an Academic Dean, and a College Director. She is currently an adjunct Professor of Psychology at Southern New Hampshire University. With over 20 years of experience, she joined Level 6 to guide clients seeking effective ways to change behavior and, ultimately, their bottom line.
